Does a REC Cut Current CO2 Emissions?

No, a REC does not cut existing CO2 emissions.

If an existing fossil-fuels electricity generating plant is retired, that can cut exizting CO2 emissions if and only if a new one isn't built.

image courtesy of groupe-edsi.com



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is Sustainability?

To some extent, this term suffers from the same problems as does the term - natural, or, better yet, "Green."  What is natural versus what isn't natural?  It's not defined in law, and as a result, to a large extent, what it means is in the eye of the beholder.  Here are some takes on it's meaning. The project in Sustainable Management of the Presidio Graduate School starts by stating the obvious "There are many ways to measure or define sustainability."  One particularly inciteful definition is "the property of being sustainable."  The AFSC defines it thus: "Sustainability: Meeting the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs."   Scripps Colleg e for Women takes a similar approach - "Sustainability: Sustainability seeks to provide the best outcomes for the human and natural environments both now and into the indefinite future."  The NADA also takes this approach...
Read more

Economics and Sustainability

Image
One key aspect of a sustainability focus is explicitly recognizing that decisions are driven by three somewhat competing objectives: Profit - People - Planet .  Another way to say this is choices are determined by examining their impact on the business, society, and the natural environment.  A term coined to describe this tripartite is The Triple Bottom Line .   A picture of The Triple bottom Line (T-B-L) appears here.  What I find critically important is in the overlap between any two and all three goals.  This is interesting to me since it will be the rare circumstance when all three goals - environmental, social, and economic - sustainability can equally be met. One implication of the T-B-L is that choice is no longer driven by economics alone.  The profitability of a particular decision is no longer the driving force behind the choice.  In one way. this is not path breaking news to real-world decision-makers.  For years now future leaders h...
Read more

What is More Important, Building Renewables or Cutting Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Removing Existing CO2?

Image
What if cutting greenhouse gas emissions (GHG), especially CO2, is not the same as increasing the share of electricity generated using renewables? Which would you pick? As an economist, such questions interest me. This kind of question interests me because we face a slew of problems and we have a limited amount of effort available to help solve them.  If we are able to cut CO2 emissions at a lower cost one way rather than some other way, why pick the more costly approach? For many folks, there is no question of deciding between cutting GHG and installing more renewables. They are assumed to be one in the same. Is there any evidence to suggest otherwise? Actually, there is. Electricity planning analysis performed by the Northwest Power Planning Council (NWPPC) is but one such body of work. In their 7th Power Plan, which was released at the beginning of 2016, is a chapter that addresses this very issue. Here's another source. What the NWPPC found is that cheaper and more e...
Read more